Visible to the public Biblio

Found 150 results

Filters: Keyword is face recognition  [Clear All Filters]
2022-09-09
White, Riley, Sprague, Nathan.  2021.  Deep Metric Learning for Code Authorship Attribution and Verification. 2021 20th IEEE International Conference on Machine Learning and Applications (ICMLA). :1089—1093.
Code authorship identification can assist in identifying creators of malware, identifying plagiarism, and giving insights in copyright infringement cases. Taking inspiration from facial recognition work, we apply recent advances in metric learning to the problem of authorship identification and verification. The metric learning approach makes it possible to measure similarity in the learned embedding space. Access to a discriminative similarity measure allows for the estimation of probability distributions that facilitate open-set classification and verification. We extend our analysis to verification based on sets of files, a previously unexplored problem domain in large-scale author identification. On closed-set tasks we achieve competitive accuracies, but do not improve on the state of the art.
Alotaiby, Turky N., Alshebeili, Saleh A., Alotibi, Gaseb.  2021.  Subject Authentication using Time-Frequency Image Textural Features. 2021 International Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Information and Communication (ICAIIC). :130—133.
The growing internet-based services such as banking and shopping have brought both ease to human's lives and challenges in user identity authentication. Different methods have been investigated for user authentication such as retina, finger print, and face recognition. This study introduces a photoplethysmogram (PPG) based user identity authentication relying on textural features extracted from time-frequency image. The PPG signal is segmented into segments and each segment is transformed into time-frequency domain using continuous wavelet transform (CWT). Then, the textural features are extracted from the time-frequency images using Haralick's method. Finally, a classifier is employed for identity authentication purposes. The proposed system achieved an average accuracy of 99.14% and 99.9% with segment lengths of one and tweeny seconds, respectively, using random forest classifier.
2022-07-29
Azhari Halim, Muhammad Arif, Othman, Mohd. Fairuz Iskandar, Abidin, Aa Zezen Zaenal, Hamid, Erman, Harum, Norharyati, Shah, Wahidah Md.  2021.  Face Recognition-based Door Locking System with Two-Factor Authentication Using OpenCV. 2021 Sixth International Conference on Informatics and Computing (ICIC). :1—7.

This project develops a face recognition-based door locking system with two-factor authentication using OpenCV. It uses Raspberry Pi 4 as the microcontroller. Face recognition-based door locking has been around for many years, but most of them only provide face recognition without any added security features, and they are costly. The design of this project is based on human face recognition and the sending of a One-Time Password (OTP) using the Twilio service. It will recognize the person at the front door. Only people who match the faces stored in its dataset and then inputs the correct OTP will have access to unlock the door. The Twilio service and image processing algorithm Local Binary Pattern Histogram (LBPH) has been adopted for this system. Servo motor operates as a mechanism to access the door. Results show that LBPH takes a short time to recognize a face. Additionally, if an unknown face is detected, it will log this instance into a "Fail" file and an accompanying CSV sheet.

2022-07-05
Schoneveld, Liam, Othmani, Alice.  2021.  Towards a General Deep Feature Extractor for Facial Expression Recognition. 2021 IEEE International Conference on Image Processing (ICIP). :2339—2342.
The human face conveys a significant amount of information. Through facial expressions, the face is able to communicate numerous sentiments without the need for verbalisation. Visual emotion recognition has been extensively studied. Recently several end-to-end trained deep neural networks have been proposed for this task. However, such models often lack generalisation ability across datasets. In this paper, we propose the Deep Facial Expression Vector ExtractoR (DeepFEVER), a new deep learning-based approach that learns a visual feature extractor general enough to be applied to any other facial emotion recognition task or dataset. DeepFEVER outperforms state-of-the-art results on the AffectNet and Google Facial Expression Comparison datasets. DeepFEVER’s extracted features also generalise extremely well to other datasets – even those unseen during training – namely, the Real-World Affective Faces (RAF) dataset.
Bae, Jin Hee, Kim, Minwoo, Lim, Joon S..  2021.  Emotion Detection and Analysis from Facial Image using Distance between Coordinates Feature. 2021 International Conference on Information and Communication Technology Convergence (ICTC). :494—497.
Facial expression recognition has long been established as a subject of continuous research in various fields. In this study, feature extraction was conducted by calculating the distance between facial landmarks in an image. The extracted features of the relationship between each landmark and analysis were used to classify five facial expressions. We increased the data and label reliability based on our labeling work with multiple observers. Additionally, faces were recognized from the original data, and landmark coordinates were extracted and used as features. A genetic algorithm was used to select features that were relatively more helpful for classification. We performed facial recognition classification and analysis using the method proposed in this study, which showed the validity and effectiveness of the proposed method.
Liu, Weida, Fang, Jian.  2021.  Facial Expression Recognition Method Based on Cascade Convolution Neural Network. 2021 International Wireless Communications and Mobile Computing (IWCMC). :1012—1015.
In view of the problem that the convolution neural network research of facial expression recognition ignores the internal relevance of the key links, which leads to the low accuracy and speed of facial expression recognition, and can't meet the recognition requirements, a series cascade algorithm model for expression recognition of educational robot is constructed and enables the educational robot to recognize multiple students' facial expressions simultaneously, quickly and accurately in the process of movement, in the balance of the accuracy, rapidity and stability of the algorithm, based on the cascade convolution neural network model. Through the CK+ and Oulu-CASIA expression recognition database, the expression recognition experiments of this algorithm are compared with the commonly used STM-ExpLet and FN2EN cascade network algorithms. The results show that the accuracy of the expression recognition method is more than 90%. Compared with the other two commonly used cascade convolution neural network methods, the accuracy of expression recognition is significantly improved.
Wang, Caixia, Wang, Zhihui, Cui, Dong.  2021.  Facial Expression Recognition with Attention Mechanism. 2021 14th International Congress on Image and Signal Processing, BioMedical Engineering and Informatics (CISP-BMEI). :1—6.
With the development of artificial intelligence, facial expression recognition (FER) has greatly improved performance in deep learning, but there is still a lot of room for improvement in the study of combining attention to focus the network on key parts of the face. For facial expression recognition, this paper designs a network model, which use spatial transformer network to transform the input image firstly, and then adding channel attention and spatial attention to the convolutional network. In addition, in this paper, the GELU activation function is used in the convolutional network, which improves the recognition rate of facial expressions to a certain extent.
Fallah, Zahra, Ebrahimpour-Komleh, Hossein, Mousavirad, Seyed Jalaleddin.  2021.  A Novel Hybrid Pyramid Texture-Based Facial Expression Recognition. 2021 5th International Conference on Pattern Recognition and Image Analysis (IPRIA). :1—6.
Automated analysis of facial expressions is one of the most interesting and challenging problems in many areas such as human-computer interaction. Facial images are affected by many factors, such as intensity, pose and facial expressions. These factors make facial expression recognition problem a challenge. The aim of this paper is to propose a new method based on the pyramid local binary pattern (PLBP) and the pyramid local phase quantization (PLPQ), which are the extension of the local binary pattern (LBP) and the local phase quantization (LPQ) as two methods for extracting texture features. LBP operator is used to extract LBP feature in the spatial domain and LPQ operator is used to extract LPQ feature in the frequency domain. The combination of features in spatial and frequency domains can provide important information in both domains. In this paper, PLBP and PLPQ operators are separately used to extract features. Then, these features are combined to create a new feature vector. The advantage of pyramid transform domain is that it can recognize facial expressions efficiently and with high accuracy even for very low-resolution facial images. The proposed method is verified on the CK+ facial expression database. The proposed method achieves the recognition rate of 99.85% on CK+ database.
Arabian, H., Wagner-Hartl, V., Geoffrey Chase, J., Möller, K..  2021.  Facial Emotion Recognition Focused on Descriptive Region Segmentation. 2021 43rd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC). :3415—3418.
Facial emotion recognition (FER) is useful in many different applications and could offer significant benefit as part of feedback systems to train children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) who struggle to recognize facial expressions and emotions. This project explores the potential of real time FER based on the use of local regions of interest combined with a machine learning approach. Histogram of Oriented Gradients (HOG) was implemented for feature extraction, along with 3 different classifiers, 2 based on k-Nearest Neighbor and 1 using Support Vector Machine (SVM) classification. Model performance was compared using accuracy of randomly selected validation sets after training on random training sets of the Oulu-CASIA database. Image classes were distributed evenly, and accuracies of up to 98.44% were observed with small variation depending on data distributions. The region selection methodology provided a compromise between accuracy and number of extracted features, and validated the hypothesis a focus on smaller informative regions performs just as well as the entire image.
Hu, Zhibin, Yan, Chunman.  2021.  Lightweight Multi-Scale Network with Attention for Facial Expression Recognition. 2021 4th International Conference on Advanced Electronic Materials, Computers and Software Engineering (AEMCSE). :695—698.
Aiming at the problems of the traditional convolutional neural network (CNN), such as too many parameters, single scale feature and inefficiency by some useless features, a lightweight multi-scale network with attention is proposed for facial expression recognition. The network uses the lightweight convolutional neural network model Xception and combines with the convolutional block attention module (CBAM) to learn key facial features; In addition, depthwise separable convolution module with convolution kernel of 3 × 3, 5 × 5 and 7 × 7 are used to extract features of facial expression image, and the features are fused to expand the receptive field and obtain more rich facial feature information. Experiments on facial expression datasets Fer2013 and KDEF show that the expression recognition accuracy is improved by 2.14% and 2.18% than the original Xception model, and the results further verify the effectiveness of our methods.
Sun, Lanxin, Dai, JunBo, Shen, Xunbing.  2021.  Facial emotion recognition based on LDA and Facial Landmark Detection. 2021 2nd International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Education (ICAIE). :64—67.
Emotion recognition in the field of human-computer interaction refers to that the computer has the corresponding perceptual ability to predict the emotional state of human beings in advance by observing human expressions, behaviors and emotions, so as to ensure that computers can communicate emotionally with humans. The main research work of this paper is to extract facial image features by using Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) and Facial Landmark Detection after grayscale processing and cropping, and then compare the accuracy after emotion recognition and classification to determine which feature extraction method is more effective. The test results show that the accuracy rate of emotion recognition in face images can reach 73.9% by using LDA method, and 84.5% by using Facial Landmark Detection method. Therefore, facial landmarks can be used to identify emotion in face images more accurately.
Cao, HongYuan, Qi, Chao.  2021.  Facial Expression Study Based on 3D Facial Emotion Recognition. 2021 20th International Conference on Ubiquitous Computing and Communications (IUCC/CIT/DSCI/SmartCNS). :375—381.
Teaching evaluation is an indispensable key link in the modern education model. Its purpose is to promote learners' cognitive and non-cognitive development, especially emotional development. However, today's education has increasingly neglected the emotional process of learners' learning. Therefore, a method of using machines to analyze the emotional changes of learners during learning has been proposed. At present, most of the existing emotion recognition algorithms use the extraction of two-dimensional facial features from images to perform emotion prediction. Through research, it is found that the recognition rate of 2D facial feature extraction is not optimal, so this paper proposes an effective the algorithm obtains a single two-dimensional image from the input end and constructs a three-dimensional face model from the output end, thereby using 3D facial information to estimate the continuous emotion of the dimensional space and applying this method to an online learning system. Experimental results show that the algorithm has strong robustness and recognition ability.
Siyaka, Hassan Opotu, Owolabi, Olumide, Bisallah, I. Hashim.  2021.  A New Facial Image Deviation Estimation and Image Selection Algorithm (Fide-Isa) for Facial Image Recognition Systems: The Mathematical Models. 2021 1st International Conference on Multidisciplinary Engineering and Applied Science (ICMEAS). :1—7.
Deep learning models have been successful and shown to perform better in terms of accuracy and efficiency for facial recognition applications. However, they require huge amount of data samples that were well annotated to be successful. Their data requirements have led to some complications which include increased processing demands of the systems where such systems were to be deployed. Reducing the training sample sizes of deep learning models is still an open problem. This paper proposes the reduction of the number of samples required by the convolutional neutral network used in training a facial recognition system using a new Facial Image Deviation Estimation and Image Selection Algorithm (FIDE-ISA). The algorithm was used to select appropriate facial image training samples incrementally based on their facial deviation. This will reduce the need for huge dataset in training deep learning models. Preliminary results indicated a 100% accuracy for models trained with 54 images (at least 3 images per individual) and above.
2022-06-30
Jadhav, Mohit, Kulkarni, Nupur, Walhekar, Omkar.  2021.  Doodling Based CAPTCHA Authentication System. 2021 Asian Conference on Innovation in Technology (ASIANCON). :1—5.
CAPTCHA (Completely Automated Public Turing Test to tell Computers and Humans Apart) is a widely used challenge-measures to distinguish humans and computer automated programs apart. Several existing CAPTCHAs are reliable for normal users, whereas visually impaired users face a lot of problems with the CAPTCHA authentication process. CAPTCHAs such as Google reCAPTCHA alternatively provides audio CAPTCHA, but many users find it difficult to decipher due to noise, language barrier, and accent of the audio of the CAPTCHA. Existing CAPTCHA systems lack user satisfaction on smartphones thus limiting its use. Our proposed system potentially solves the problem faced by visually impaired users during the process of CAPTCHA authentication. Also, our system makes the authentication process generic across users as well as platforms.
2022-06-14
Vanitha, C. N., Malathy, S., Anitha, K., Suwathika, S..  2021.  Enhanced Security using Advanced Encryption Standards in Face Recognition. 2021 2nd International Conference on Communication, Computing and Industry 4.0 (C2I4). :1–5.
Nowadays, face recognition is used everywhere in all fields. Though the face recognition is used for security purposes there is also chance in hacking the faces which is used for face recognition. For enhancing the face security, encryption and decryption technique is used. Face cognizance has been engaged in more than a few security-connected purposes such as supervision, e-passport, and etc… The significant use of biometric raises vital private concerns, in precise if the biometric same method is carried out at a central or unfrosted servers, and calls for implementation of Privacy improving technologies. For privacy concerns the encoding and decoding is used. For achieving the result we are using the Open Computer Vision (OpenCV) tool. With the help of this tool we are going to cipher the face and decode the face with advanced encryption standards techniques. OpenCV is the tool used in this project
Dhane, Harshad, Manikandan, V. M..  2021.  A New Framework for Secure Biometric Data Transmission using Block-wise Reversible Data Hiding Through Encryption. 2021 Fifth International Conference On Intelligent Computing in Data Sciences (ICDS). :1–8.
Reversible data hiding (RDH) is an emerging area in the field of information security. The RDH schemes are widely explored in the field of cloud computing for data authentication and in medical image transmission for clinical data transmission along with medical images. The RDH schemes allow the data hider to embed sensitive information in digital content in such a way that later it can be extracted while recovering the original image. In this research, we explored the use of the RDH through the encryption scheme in a biometric authentication system. The internet of things (IoT) enabled biometric authentication systems are very common nowadays. In general, in biometric authentication, computationally complex tasks such as feature extraction and feature matching will be performed in a cloud server. The user-side devices will capture biometric data such as the face, fingerprint, or iris and it will be directly communicated to the cloud server for further processing. Since the confidentiality of biometric data needs to be maintained during the transmission, the original biometric data will be encrypted using any one of the data encryption techniques. In this manuscript, we propose the use of RDH through encryption approach to transmit two different biometric data as a single file without compromising confidentiality. The proposed scheme will ensure the integrity of the biometric data during transmission. For data hiding purposes, we have used a block-wise RDH through encryption scheme. The experimental study of the proposed scheme is carried out by embedding fingerprint data in the face images. The validation of the proposed scheme is carried out by extracting the fingerprint details from the face images during image decryption. The scheme ensures the exact recovery of face image images and fingerprint data at the receiver site.
Hofbauer, Heinz, Martínez-Díaz, Yoanna, Kirchgasser, Simon, Méndez-Vázquez, Heydi, Uhl, Andreas.  2021.  Highly Efficient Protection of Biometric Face Samples with Selective JPEG2000 Encryption. ICASSP 2021 - 2021 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing (ICASSP). :2580–2584.
When biometric databases grow larger, a security breach or leak can affect millions. In order to protect against such a threat, the use of encryption is a natural choice. However, a biometric identification attempt then requires the decryption of a potential huge database, making a traditional approach potentially unfeasible. The use of selective JPEG2000 encryption can reduce the encryption’s computational load and enable a secure storage of biometric sample data. In this paper we will show that selective encryption of face biometric samples is secure. We analyze various encoding settings of JPEG2000, selective encryption parameters on the "Labeled Faces in the Wild" database and apply several traditional and deep learning based face recognition methods.
2022-06-09
Tamiya, Hiroto, Isshiki, Toshiyuki, Mori, Kengo, Obana, Satoshi, Ohki, Tetsushi.  2021.  Improved Post-quantum-secure Face Template Protection System Based on Packed Homomorphic Encryption. 2021 International Conference of the Biometrics Special Interest Group (BIOSIG). :1–5.
This paper proposes an efficient face template protection system based on homomorphic encryption. By developing a message packing method suitable for the calculation of the squared Euclidean distance, the proposed system computes the squared Euclidean distance between facial features by a single homomorphic multiplication. Our experimental results show the transaction time of the proposed system is about 14 times faster than that of the existing face template protection system based on homomorphic encryption presented in BIOSIG2020.
2022-05-10
Ahmed, Foez, Shahriar, T. A. M. Ragib, Paul, Robi, Ahammad, Arif.  2021.  Design and Development of a Smart Surveillance System for Security of an Institution. 2021 International Conference on Electronics, Communications and Information Technology (ICECIT). :1–4.
Conventional Security Systems are improving with the advancement of Internet of Things (IoT) based technology. For better security, in addition to the currently available technology, surveillance systems are used. In this research, a Smart Surveillance System with machine-learning capabilities is designed to detect security breaches and it will resolve safety concerns. Machine learning algorithms are implemented to detect intruders as well as suspicious activities. Enery efficiency is the major concern for constant monitoring systems. As a result, the designed system focuses on power consumption by calibrating the system so that it can work on bare minimum power and additionally provides the required output. Fire sensor has also been integrated to detect fire for safety purposes. By adding upon the security infrastructure, next-generation smart surveillance systems can be created for a safe future. The developed system contains the necessary tools to recognize intruders by face recognition. Also using the ambient sensors (PIR sensor, fire detecting sensor), a secure environment is provided during working and non-working hours. The system shows high accuracy in human & flame detection. A more reliable security system can be created with the further development of this research.
2022-05-05
Gaikwad, Bipin, Prakash, PVBSS, Karmakar, Abhijit.  2021.  Edge-based real-time face logging system for security applications. 2021 12th International Conference on Computing Communication and Networking Technologies (ICCCNT). :1—6.
In this work, we have proposed a state-of-the-art face logging system that detects and logs high quality cropped face images of the people in real-time for security applications. Multiple strategies based on resolution, velocity and symmetry of faces have been applied to obtain best quality face images. The proposed system handles the issue of motion blur in the face images by determining the velocities of the detections. The output of the system is the face database, where four faces for each detected person are stored along with the time stamp and ID number tagged to it. The facial features are extracted by our system, which are used to search the person-of-interest instantly. The proposed system has been implemented in a docker container environment on two edge devices: the powerful NVIDIA Jetson TX2 and the cheaper NVIDIA Jetson N ano. The light and fast face detector (LFFD) used for detection, and ResN et50 used for facial feature extraction are optimized using TensorRT over these edge devices. In our experiments, the proposed system achieves the True Acceptance Rate (TAR) of 0.94 at False Acceptance Rate (FAR) of 0.01 while detecting the faces at 20–30 FPS on NVIDIA Jetson TX2 and about 8–10 FPS on NVIDIA Jetson N ano device. The advantage of our system is that it is easily deployable at multiple locations and also scalable based on application requirement. Thus it provides a realistic solution to face logging application as the query or suspect can be searched instantly, which may not only help in investigation of incidents but also in prevention of untoward incidents.
2022-04-19
Thushara, G A, Bhanu, S. Mary Saira.  2021.  A Survey on Secured Data Sharing Using Ciphertext Policy Attribute Based Encryption in Cloud. 2021 8th International Conference on Smart Computing and Communications (ICSCC). :170–177.
Cloud computing facilitates the access of applications and data from any location by using any device with an internet connection. It enables multiple applications and users to access the same data resources. Cloud based information sharing is a technique that allows researchers to communicate and collaborate, that leads to major new developments in the field. It also enables users to access data over the cloud easily and conveniently. Privacy, authenticity and confidentiality are the three main challenges while sharing data in cloud. There are many methods which support secure data sharing in cloud environment such as Attribute Based Encryption(ABE), Role Based Encryption, Hierarchical Based Encryption, and Identity Based Encryption. ABE provides secure access control mechanisms for integrity. It is classified as Key Policy Attribute Based Encryption(KP-ABE) and Ciphertext Policy Attribute Based Encryption(CP-ABE) based on access policy integration. In KPABE, access structure is incorporated with user's private key, and data are encrypted over a defined attributes. Moreover, in CPABE, access structure is embedded with ciphertext. This paper reviews CP-ABE methods that have been developed so far for achieving secured data sharing in cloud environment.
2022-03-09
Pichetjamroen, Sasakorn, Rattanalerdnusorn, Ekkachan, Vorakulpipat, Chalee, Pichetjamroen, Achara.  2021.  Multi-Factor based Face Validation Attendance System with Contactless Design in Training Event. 2021 18th International Conference on Electrical Engineering/Electronics, Computer, Telecommunications and Information Technology (ECTI-CON). :637—640.
Various methods for face validation-based authentication systems have been applied in a number of access control applications. However, using only one biometric factor such as facial data may limit accuracy and use, and is not practical in a real environment. This paper presents the implementation of a face time attendance system with an additional factor, a QR code to improve accuracy. This two- factor authentication system was developed in the form of a kiosk with a contactless process, which emerged due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The experiment was conducted at a well- known training event in Thailand. The proposed two-factor system was evaluated in terms of accuracy and satisfaction. Additionally, it was compared to a traditional single-factor system using only face recognition. The results confirm that the proposed two-factor scheme is more effective and did not incorrectly identify any users.
2022-02-22
Martin, Peter, Fan, Jian, Kim, Taejin, Vesey, Konrad, Greenwald, Lloyd.  2021.  Toward Effective Moving Target Defense Against Adversarial AI. MILCOM 2021 - 2021 IEEE Military Communications Conference (MILCOM). :993—998.
Deep learning (DL) models have been shown to be vulnerable to adversarial attacks. DL model security against adversarial attacks is critical to using DL-trained models in forward deployed systems, e.g. facial recognition, document characterization, or object detection. We provide results and lessons learned applying a moving target defense (MTD) strategy against iterative, gradient-based adversarial attacks. Our strategy involves (1) training a diverse ensemble of DL models, (2) applying randomized affine input transformations to inputs, and (3) randomizing output decisions. We report a primary lesson that this strategy is ineffective against a white-box adversary, which could completely circumvent output randomization using a deterministic surrogate. We reveal how our ensemble models lacked the diversity necessary for effective MTD. We also evaluate our MTD strategy against a black-box adversary employing an ensemble surrogate model. We conclude that an MTD strategy against black-box adversarial attacks crucially depends on lack of transferability between models.
2022-01-11
McCarthy, Andrew, Andriotis, Panagiotis, Ghadafi, Essam, Legg, Phil.  2021.  Feature Vulnerability and Robustness Assessment against Adversarial Machine Learning Attacks. 2021 International Conference on Cyber Situational Awareness, Data Analytics and Assessment (CyberSA). :1–8.
Whilst machine learning has been widely adopted for various domains, it is important to consider how such techniques may be susceptible to malicious users through adversarial attacks. Given a trained classifier, a malicious attack may attempt to craft a data observation whereby the data features purposefully trigger the classifier to yield incorrect responses. This has been observed in various image classification tasks, including falsifying road sign detection and facial recognition, which could have severe consequences in real-world deployment. In this work, we investigate how these attacks could impact on network traffic analysis, and how a system could perform misclassification of common network attacks such as DDoS attacks. Using the CICIDS2017 data, we examine how vulnerable the data features used for intrusion detection are to perturbation attacks using FGSM adversarial examples. As a result, our method provides a defensive approach for assessing feature robustness that seeks to balance between classification accuracy whilst minimising the attack surface of the feature space.
2022-01-10
Matsunami, Tomoaki, Uchida, Hidetsugu, Abe, Narishige, Yamada, Shigefumi.  2021.  Learning by Environment Clusters for Face Presentation Attack Detection. 2021 International Conference of the Biometrics Special Interest Group (BIOSIG). :1–5.
Face recognition has been used widely for personal authentication. However, there is a problem that it is vulnerable to a presentation attack in which a counterfeit such as a photo is presented to a camera to impersonate another person. Although various presentation attack detection methods have been proposed, these methods have not been able to sufficiently cope with the diversity of the heterogeneous environments including presentation attack instruments (PAIs) and lighting conditions. In this paper, we propose Learning by Environment Clusters (LEC) which divides training data into some clusters of similar photographic environments and trains bona-fide and attack classification models for each cluster. Experimental results using Replay-Attack, OULU-NPU, and CelebA-Spoof show the EER of the conventional method which trains one classification model from all data was 20.0%, but LEC can achieve 13.8% EER when using binarized statistical image features (BSIFs) and support vector machine used as the classification method.